For reasons that remain unclear to the fandom, the only official, mass-produced, region-coded release of the show on DVD happened in . Distributed by Beyond Home Entertainment, a single DVD titled Randy Cunningham: 9th Grade Ninja – Swampy’s Secret was released in 2013.

Some versions found at DVD Planet Store or eCrater are "on-demand" transfers, often used to preserve digital media into physical formats for personal collections.

The truth is harsh: Disney has abandoned this show in the physical realm. The Randy Cunningham DVD is a ghost. Until a boutique label like Shout! Factory or Mill Creek Entertainment picks up the rights (a very long shot), the only way to honor the Ninja is to scream into the void of social media, demanding a re-release.

Because of this unique blend of humor, heart, and action, the show garnered a dedicated cult following. Even years after its cancellation, the fandom remains active, creating fan art, memes, and essays dissecting the character arcs of the students of Norrisville High.